top of page
Writer's pictureJulie Danaher

Should You Remodel or Sell Your Home? Key Considerations to Guide Your Decision

Love it or list it Vermont

When your home no longer feels like the perfect fit, the decision to remodel or sell can be challenging. Both options come with distinct advantages and drawbacks, and the right choice depends on your personal circumstances, goals, and finances. Are you looking to modernize your space or create better functionality? Or is it time to move to a new location or a home that better suits your lifestyle?


This guide will help you weigh the key considerations of remodeling versus selling, from costs and return on investment to lifestyle needs and market factors. With the right information, you can confidently decide whether to stay and transform your home or start fresh somewhere new.

Contemporary kitchen with a large wooden island, barstools, and a sleek backsplash. The space is well-lit with pendant lights and natural light from multiple windows.
A spacious and stylish kitchen perfect for gatherings or meal prep.

Understanding the Reasons for Remodeling

Modernizing the Look and Feel of Your Home

Homeowners often choose remodeling projects to update the aesthetics of their homes. A modern look can significantly enhance your living experience while also boosting the property’s value.


Enhancing Functionality and Usability

Remodeling can address functionality issues. Whether it’s improving kitchen workflows, adding storage, or optimizing living spaces, the goal is to make your home better suited to your needs.


Key Questions to Ask Before Deciding

Will You Recoup the Investment?

Consider whether the remodeling costs will be recouped when you sell the home. For instance, a $40,000 remodel may not increase your home’s value by the same amount.


Does Your Current Home Meet Your Lifestyle Needs?

Assess if your home’s layout, location, and size are sufficient for your family’s needs. If not, a new home might be a better option.


Three Essential Things to Consider Before Remodeling

Ask yourself:

  • What are the top three things I would change about my home?

  • If answers include superficial changes (e.g., kitchen, bath, carpets), a remodel may suffice.

  • If answers point to structural or locational dissatisfaction, selling might be the solution.



Spacious white kitchen with farmhouse-style sink, marble countertops, and natural light pouring in through the window. A small plant decorates the counter near the sink.
A bright and airy kitchen designed for both style and functionality

The Costs of Common Home Renovations

Kitchen Renovation: Costs and Impact

A kitchen remodel typically ranges from $25,000 to $50,000. This investment often has a significant impact on the home's functionality and resale value.


Bathroom Updates: Worth the Expense?

Bathroom renovations can cost between $15,000 and $35,000. Modern, updated bathrooms are a key selling point and a personal luxury.


Smaller Updates Like Flooring, Painting, and Fixtures

Smaller projects such as painting ($600-$800 per room), flooring updates ($3,000-$6,000 per room), and new fixtures are more budget-friendly ways to refresh your space.


  • Major Additions: Costs between $80,000-$120,000.

  • Finishing a Basement: Ranges from $25,000-$50,000.

  • Practical Considerations: Think about the disruption of living in a remodeling environment and assess the quality of life improvements.

  • DIY Ideas: Painting cabinets, installing fixtures, or small updates can save costs but require proper research and preparation.

  • Hidden Costs: Economic climate and market conditions may affect the ROI of remodeling, making it essential to consult experts.

  • Other Considerations: Determine whether remodeling aligns with your needs or external influences, ensuring that decisions improve quality of life.


When Selling Might Be the Better Option

Signs Your Current Home No Longer Fits

If your home’s size, location, or style no longer meets your needs, selling may be the right choice. For example, a lack of space or desire to relocate are strong indicators.


Considering Economic and Market Factors

External factors, such as the real estate market’s strength and mortgage rates, play a big role in determining whether selling is more advantageous.


Benefits of a Free Market Analysis

A professional market analysis can provide valuable insights into your home’s current value and potential sale price. This helps in making a more informed decision.


Bright modern bathroom with a freestanding tub, glass-enclosed shower, and marble countertops. A potted plant adds a touch of greenery near a large window.
A serene and luxurious bathroom setup for a relaxing retreat.

Factors That Complicate Remodeling Decisions

Potential for Over-Budget Projects

Even with careful planning, renovations often exceed budgets due to unforeseen costs like material price hikes or additional repairs.


The Stress of Living in a Remodel Zone

Living through renovations can be disruptive and stressful. Evaluate whether the temporary inconvenience is worth the long-term gain.


Knowing When to DIY vs. Hire Professionals

DIY projects can save money, but some tasks require professional expertise. Identify which projects you can handle and which to outsource.


How to Approach the Remodeling Process

Researching and Hiring the Right Contractors

Thoroughly vet contractors by checking references, viewing portfolios, and comparing quotes. The right professional can make or break your project.


Planning and Budgeting Effectively

Detail your project’s scope, costs, and timelines. Sticking to a clear plan can prevent budget overruns and delays.


High-Value Renovations That Provide Good ROI

Focus on updates that yield a high return on investment, such as kitchen upgrades, bathroom remodels, or adding functional spaces like finished basements.


Clarifying Your Needs and Goals

Writing Down Priorities with Your Family

Discussing your family’s needs and desires can clarify whether remodeling or selling aligns with your collective goals.


Consulting Realtors and Contractors for Professional Insight

Realtors can provide market expertise, while contractors offer realistic renovation cost estimates. Both perspectives are crucial for informed decision-making.


Final Thoughts on Remodeling vs. Selling

Weighing Your Needs, Wants, and Practical Considerations

Deciding between remodeling and selling is deeply personal. Consider your financial situation, future plans, and the potential impact on your lifestyle.


Making the Decision That Improves Your Quality of Life

Ultimately, the best choice is one that aligns with your goals and improves your day-to-day living experience. Whether you remodel or move, make the decision with confidence.

Comments


bottom of page